When to Take Social Security: Smart Strategies to Avoid Costly Mistakes

In This Article...

Deciding when to claim Social Security is one of the most important financial choices you’ll make. Claim too early, and you could lose out on thousands. This guide explains how to time your benefits based on health, income, life expectancy, and retirement goals.

Did you know that claiming Social Security at age 62 could permanently reduce your benefits by 30%? Yet waiting until age 70 might increase them to 124% of your full benefit amount.

The financial implications are substantial. Despite the potential for higher payments, fewer than 10% of retirees delayed claiming until age 70 in 2022. Monthly benefits rise dramatically from $1,274.87 at age 62 to $1,963.48 at age 70, a difference that profoundly affects retirement security and lifestyle options.

Deciding when to take Social Security ranks among the most consequential financial choices you’ll face. For retirees reaching 65, life expectancy extends to 84 years for men and 87 for women. Your claiming decision therefore influences decades of retirement income.

What strategies will help you maximize benefits while avoiding costly errors? How should personal factors shape your claiming age? This article examines key considerations that lead to optimal Social Security decisions for your specific circumstances and long-term financial security.

The Three Critical Ages for Social Security

Social Security claiming decisions hinge on three crucial age milestones that permanently determine your lifetime benefit amount. Each threshold offers distinct advantages and limitations, requiring thoughtful analysis based on personal circumstances.

Age 62: Minimum benefits but maximum time

Claiming Social Security at 62 provides immediate access to benefits, albeit at a significantly reduced rate. Your monthly payment faces a permanent reduction of up to 30% compared to your full retirement age benefit. Individuals born in 1960 or later receive only 70% of their full benefit amount each month for their entire retirement.

The precise reduction varies by birth year and claiming timeline. The Social Security Administration applies a reduction of 5/9 of one percent monthly for the first 36 months before full retirement age. Claims filed more than 36 months early face additional decreases of 5/12 of one percent per month.

Consider the 2025 maximum benefit figures for context. Age 62 retirement in 2025 yields a maximum benefit of $2,831 monthly, substantially below what delayed claiming provides.

Early claiming might prove financially advantageous when:

  • Immediate income needs exist
  • Health conditions suggest shortened life expectancy
  • Maximizing total benefit receipt duration matters

Full retirement age: 100% of your earned benefit

Full retirement age (FRA) represents the age at which you qualify for 100% of your earned Social Security benefit. This threshold varies according to birth year:

  • Born 1943-1954: FRA is 66
  • Born 1955-1959: FRA increases incrementally
  • Born 1960 or later: FRA is 67

Claiming at full retirement age delivers your complete calculated benefit without adjustments. A 2025 retirement at full retirement age offers a maximum monthly benefit of $4,018.

The financial advantage proves substantial compared to early claiming. Recent Social Security Administration data shows average monthly benefits reach $1,844.83 at age 67 versus $1,274.87 at age 62.

Full retirement age also carries significant implications for spousal benefits. Spouses claiming at full retirement age receive 50% of their partner’s full retirement benefit, compared to merely 32.5% if claimed at age 62.

Age 70: Maximum monthly payments

Postponing Social Security beyond full retirement age generates valuable “delayed retirement credits.” Each year of delay until age 70 increases your benefit by 8%.

For those with a full retirement age of 67, waiting until 70 produces a permanent 24% benefit increase (8% × 3 years). These increases provide significantly higher lifetime income.

The 2025 maximum benefit at age 70 reaches $5,108 monthly, approximately 77% more than early claiming at 62.

Delayed claiming particularly benefits:

  • Those anticipating longevity beyond age 80-82
  • Higher-earning spouses seeking to maximize survivor benefits
  • Retirees with adequate alternative income sources until age 70

Financial professionals frequently recommend this approach for those financially able to wait, particularly since approximately one-third of today’s 65-year-olds will surpass age 90.

No additional benefit increases accrue beyond age 70. Consequently, even if employment continues, benefits should commence no later than your 70th birthday to avoid forfeiting earned credits.

Each age milestone represents a distinct approach to Social Security optimization based on your unique health outlook, financial resources, and retirement needs.

Calculating Your Break-Even Point

Understanding the financial implications of when to take Social Security demands calculating your break-even point, a pivotal figure that serves as a cornerstone for informed claiming decisions. This calculation reveals which claiming age maximizes your lifetime benefits.

How to determine your personal break-even age

Your Social Security break-even point is the age at which total benefits received from delayed claiming equal and subsequently exceed what earlier claiming would have provided. This represents the threshold where patience begins yielding financial dividends.

Determining your personal break-even age requires these precise steps:

  1. Obtain estimated benefit amounts at different ages (62, full retirement age, and 70) from your Social Security statement
  2. Calculate the monthly difference between your early and delayed benefits
  3. Determine the “missed opportunity cost” (total benefits foregone by waiting)
  4. Divide the missed opportunity cost by the monthly benefit difference

Consider this illustration: With a monthly benefit of $1,400 at age 62 versus $2,500 at age 70, your monthly benefit difference equals $1,100. The missed opportunity cost totals $134,400 ($1,400 × 96 months from age 62 to 70). Your break-even calculation yields $134,400 ÷ $1,100 = 122 months (approximately 10 years) beyond age 70, establishing your break-even age approximately 80.

Standard break-even ages typically fall around 73.7 years for claiming at 62 versus full retirement age, while claiming at full retirement age versus age 70 produces a break-even age of approximately 79 years.

When early claiming wins financially

Early Social Security claiming proves financially advantageous under specific circumstances, primarily involving health expectations and immediate financial requirements.

Serious health concerns or family health history indicating shorter-than-average longevity may prevent you from reaching your break-even age. Under these conditions, earlier claiming maximizes lifetime benefits. Financial experts acknowledge that claiming early represents “the appropriate choice for both providing income and helping offset higher medical outlays”.

Early claiming also benefits those facing minimal risk of outliving their assets, ultra-high-net-worth individuals, retirees with adequate pensions, or those with modest, predictable expenses. Such circumstances allow immediate financial access while distributing tax liability across more years.

Additionally, accessing Social Security at 62 may reduce reliance on investment portfolios during market downturns, potentially preserving legacy assets.

When delayed claiming provides greater lifetime benefits

Conversely, delaying your Social Security claim often yields superior lifetime benefits under multiple scenarios.

Projected longevity beyond your break-even age of 78-81 means waiting to claim delivers greater lifetime benefits. Statistical analysis demonstrates that with a 4% real return, individuals must survive to age 89 for delaying benefits from age 67 to 70 to prove advantageous.

Delayed claiming functions as longevity insurance, protecting against asset depletion. This strategy gains importance as life expectancy increase, with substantial numbers of today’s 65-year-olds reaching their 90s.

The higher-earning spouse in a marriage should evaluate delaying benefits to maximize survivor benefits. This approach ensures the surviving spouse receives the highest possible benefit throughout their remaining lifetime.

Delayed claiming offers tax advantages for retirees with substantial assets. Social Security delay provides an implied return of approximately 3%, essentially risk-free, frequently exceeding conservative investment returns while potentially lowering overall tax obligations.

Your optimal Social Security claiming age ultimately depends on your specific circumstances, health outlook, financial resources, and family considerations all substantially influence your most advantageous claiming strategy.

Coordinating Social Security With Other Retirement Income

Maximizing retirement security requires more than determining when to take Social Security. The true financial advantage emerges through strategic coordination of benefits with additional retirement income sources, creating tax-efficient, sustainable income throughout retirement.

Sequence of withdrawals strategy

Does your withdrawal sequence impact retirement security? Financial professionals confirm that tapping accounts in the right order dramatically affects tax liability and asset longevity. Most experts recommend this specific sequence:

  1. Income sources (Social Security, annuities, etc.) and Required Minimum Distributions (RMDs)
  2. Taxable accounts (standard brokerage accounts)
  3. Tax-deferred accounts (401(k)s, traditional IRAs)
  4. Tax-exempt accounts (Roth IRAs, Roth 401(k)s)

This methodical approach allows tax-advantaged accounts extended growth time, potentially increasing after-tax retirement income.

Notable exceptions warrant consideration. Estate planning objectives might dictate preserving taxable accounts since their cost basis resets at death, eliminating unrealized capital gains taxes. Strategic Roth conversions during lower-income years can minimize future RMDs while generating tax-free growth potential.

Using retirement accounts to delay Social Security

What role might retirement accounts play in Social Security timing? One particularly effective strategy employs retirement savings to bridge income requirements between retirement and age 70, enabling your Social Security benefit to grow by 8% annually beyond full retirement age.

Those possessing adequate retirement savings can initially draw from these accounts while allowing Social Security benefits to increase substantially. This approach effectively converts a portion of retirement assets into guaranteed lifetime income. A prominent retirement researcher notes that individuals postponing Social Security often initially rely more heavily on investment portfolios but subsequently require smaller withdrawals once enhanced Social Security payments commence.

Roth IRA withdrawals present another option for supplementing employment income instead of claiming Social Security prematurely. Roth contributions permit tax-free withdrawals without penalties, functioning as an excellent bridge to delayed claiming.

Pension coordination tactics

How do pensions interact with Social Security benefits? Many employer pensions integrate directly with Social Security, explicitly accounting for Social Security benefits within their formulas. This integration, originally designed to prevent discrimination favoring highly compensated employees, allows employers to avoid duplicative retirement income contributions.

Following the 1986 Tax Reform Act’s implementation, reduced Social Security benefits trigger automatic compensation through integrated pension plans, which provide enhanced pension payments. Beyond this automatic adjustment, optimal coordination requires strategic timing of pension and Social Security claims.

Government pension recipients with non-Social Security-covered employment should carefully examine the Windfall Elimination Provision and Government Pension Offset, which may substantially reduce Social Security benefits.

Annuity considerations

Social Security operates functionally similar to an annuity, contributions during working years finance lifetime retirement payments. Many financial experts consider Social Security among the most valuable retirement income streams available.

Unlike commercial annuity products, Social Security benefits include inflation protection and government guarantees. These features provide crucial protection against longevity risk—the possibility of outliving your financial resources.

What role might private annuities play alongside Social Security? Commercial annuities can complement Social Security by providing additional guaranteed income. Basic annuity structures include Single Premium Income Annuities (SPIAs) delivering immediate lifetime income and Deferred Income Annuities (DIAs) initiating payments at future dates. Optional features encompass joint and survivor benefits ensuring continued spousal payments and various refund provisions.

Delayed Social Security claiming delivers superior payout rates and stronger inflation protection compared to commercial annuities, making it the most efficient initial step for those contemplating annuity purchases.

Smart Strategies for Couples

Married couples possess distinct advantages for maximizing Social Security benefits unavailable to single individuals. The strategic claiming decisions couples make can yield thousands of additional dollars in lifetime benefits while ensuring superior financial protection for the surviving spouse.

Maximizing survivor benefits

What happens to Social Security benefits when one spouse dies? The surviving spouse becomes eligible to claim either their own benefit or their deceased spouse’s benefit—whichever is higher. When the higher-earning spouse delays claiming until age 70, they simultaneously maximize their own benefit and potentially enhance their partner’s future survivor benefit. This protection delivers particular value when the higher earner predeceases their spouse.

Survivor benefits eligibility begins at age 60 (age 50 for disabled survivors), with benefits incrementally increasing until the survivor reaches full retirement age. At full retirement age, the surviving spouse receives the full 100% of the deceased spouse’s benefit amount. Early claiming permanently reduces these benefits—claiming at age 60 provides only 71.5% of the deceased spouse’s benefit amount.

Survivor benefits offer exceptional flexibility unavailable with standard retirement benefits. Survivors may:

  • File for survivor benefits initially, then switch to their own retirement benefit later if higher
  • Begin with their own retirement benefit, then transition to survivor benefits later

This strategic switching option remains unavailable for regular spousal benefits, creating a powerful financial planning opportunity unique to survivor situations.

Spousal benefit coordination

How can couples with disparate earning histories maximize their combined benefits? Social Security provides spousal benefits that can reach 50% of the higher earner’s benefit (when claimed at full retirement age). This provision helps equalize retirement income between partners when one spouse has accumulated substantially lower lifetime earnings.

Financial professionals frequently advocate a “split strategy” approach where spouses claim at different ages. This typically involves the lower-earning spouse claiming earlier while the higher-earning spouse delays until age 70. Such coordination provides immediate household income while simultaneously maximizing the higher earner’s benefit amount.

This approach proves most effective when:

  • One spouse’s primary insurance amount falls below 50% of the other’s
  • The couple possesses sufficient alternative resources to support delaying one benefit
  • The lower-earning spouse faces health conditions suggesting reduced longevity

The fundamental principle couples must recognize: Social Security benefits represent not merely individual entitlements but components of a coordinated lifetime income strategy. With methodical planning, these approaches substantially enhance retirement security for both partners throughout their remaining years.

Common Mistakes to Avoid When Claiming Benefits

Despite meticulous planning, certain Social Security oversights can produce substantial financial consequences. Several critical errors warrant particular attention when to take Social Security.

Not understanding the earnings test

The earnings test creates widespread confusion among early benefit claimants who continue working before reaching full retirement age. During 2025, the Social Security Administration withheld $1 for every $2 earned above $23,400 for beneficiaries more than one year from full retirement age. Those within one year of full retirement age faced a higher threshold of $62,160, with only $1 withheld for every $3 earned beyond this amount.

Does this reduction constitute permanent benefit loss? No. Upon reaching full retirement age, your monthly benefit increases to account for previously withheld amounts. The earnings test functions not as a penalty but as a timing adjustment for benefit distribution—an important distinction that should not necessarily discourage continued employment.

Overlooking ex-spouse benefits

Divorce introduces complex Social Security considerations. Former spouses may qualify for benefits based on an ex-spouse’s earnings record when the marriage lasted at least 10 years and the claiming individual remains unmarried. At full retirement age, these benefits can reach 50% of the ex-spouse’s full benefit amount.

Most remarkable is the ability to claim these benefits regardless of whether your former spouse has applied for retirement benefits, provided your divorce occurred at least two years prior. The Social Security Administration maintains complete confidentiality, never notifying your former spouse about your claim. Furthermore, your benefit claim has no impact on their payment amount.

Failing to consider longevity risk

Asset depletion during extended longevity represents a formidable retirement hazard. Statistical analysis indicates a 90% probability that at least one spouse in a married couple will survive beyond age 85. This demographic reality transforms delayed claiming into valuable insurance against longevity risk.

While mortality contemplation proves uncomfortable, your family history provides essential indicators of potential lifespan. Individuals from families with extensive longevity typically benefit from delayed claiming, while those with shorter family lifespans might maximize benefits through earlier claiming strategies.

Missing the Medicare enrollment window

Your Medicare Initial Enrollment Period spans seven months, beginning three months before your 65th birthday. Enrollment window oversight can trigger permanent late enrollment penalties and significant coverage gaps. These penalties persist for the entire duration of your Part B coverage.

While automatic enrollment applies to certain beneficiaries, most individuals must proactively register during their Initial Enrollment Period. Should you miss this critical window, your only recourse becomes waiting for the General Enrollment Period (January 1-March 31), potentially creating an extended period without medical coverage.

Conclusion

Social Security claiming decisions profoundly shape your retirement lifestyle and financial security. What factors should inform your decision about when to take Social Security? A comprehensive evaluation must include your health outlook, financial resources, marital status, and specific retirement objectives.

Early claiming at age 62 provides immediate benefit access. However, patience until full retirement age or age 70 can dramatically increase your monthly payments. Research suggests most retirees derive greater financial advantage from delayed claiming, particularly those expecting longevity beyond 80 years or seeking to maximize survivor benefits for a spouse.

Does your Social Security strategy align with your broader retirement framework? Strategic coordination between Social Security and your other income sources, pensions, retirement accounts, and investment income—creates more tax-efficient, sustainable income throughout your retirement years.

Your optimal claiming age ultimately depends on your individual circumstances. Invest time understanding available options, calculating relevant break-even points, and assessing how health conditions and family longevity patterns might influence your most advantageous claiming age. This knowledge foundation enables confident decision-making that supports long-term financial security throughout retirement.

What are the key ages to consider when deciding when to claim Social Security benefits?

The three critical ages are 62 (earliest eligibility), full retirement age (varies based on birth year), and 70 (maximum benefit). Claiming at 62 results in reduced benefits, while delaying until 70 can increase your monthly payment by up to 24%.

How does my health affect my Social Security claiming decision?

Your health and family health history are crucial factors. If you have chronic conditions or a family history of shorter lifespans, claiming earlier might be beneficial. However, if you expect to live beyond your early 80s, delaying benefits could provide greater lifetime income.

What strategies can married couples use to maximize their Social Security benefits?

Couples can use strategies like having the lower-earning spouse claim earlier while the higher-earning spouse delays until 70. This approach provides some immediate income while maximizing the higher earner’s benefit, which can also increase potential survivor benefits.

How can I coordinate Social Security with other retirement income sources?

Consider using retirement savings to delay claiming Social Security, allowing your benefit to grow. Also, plan your withdrawal sequence from various accounts (taxable, tax-deferred, and tax-exempt) to optimize your overall tax situation and preserve your assets.

What common mistakes should I avoid when claiming Social Security benefits?

Common mistakes include not understanding the earnings test if working while claiming early, overlooking ex-spouse benefits, failing to consider longevity risk, and missing the Medicare enrollment window. Be sure to educate yourself on these aspects to make informed decisions.

The commentary on this article reflects the personal opinions, viewpoints and analyses of the author, Eddy Agyeman, and should not be regarded as a description of advisory services provided by Foundations Investment Advisors, LLC (“Foundations”), or performance returns of any Foundations client. The views reflected in the commentary are subject to change at any time without notice. Any mention of a particular security and related performance data is not a recommendation to buy or sell that security, or any security. Foundations manages its clients’ accounts using a variety of investment techniques and strategies, which are not necessarily discussed in the commentary. Foundations deems reliable any statistical data or information obtained from or prepared by third party sources that is included in any commentary, but in no way guarantees its accuracy or completeness.

Fill in this form & get this free Booklet


Fill in this form & get this free Booklet


Fill in this form & get this free Booklet


Fill in this form & get this free Booklet


Fill in this form & get this free Booklet


Fill in this form & get this free Booklet


Fill in this form & get this free Booklet